What is T1?
What is DSL?
What is ADSL?
What is SDSL?
What IDSL?
How do T1 and DSL Internet Access Compare?
T1 is based on a industry standard technology used to access the Internet at speeds from 384K to 1.5M. T1 is a far-reaching, fast access solution designed for businesses with high bandwidth needs.
DSL or Digital Subscriber Line uses standard voice grade lines to provide Internet access at speeds from 128K to 1.5M. Because DSL uses voice grade lines, the end user location must be within 3 miles of the nearest telephone central office. DSL is a relatively low cost solution designed for small-to-medium offices or home office/home users who do not require guaranteed high availability.
ADSL stands for Asymmetrical Digital Subscriber Line. This means that the speed is different in both directions. For example, a common DSL package includes a speed options of 768/128 Kbps. This means the transfer speed down is 768 Kbps (kilobytes per second) whereas the speed up is 128 Kbps. ADSL is ideal for email and general surfing. However, the slower upload times may negatively impact VPN performance for remote users.
SDSL stands for Symmetrical Digital Subscriber line. Unlike ADSL, the speeds for Symmetrical Digital Subscriber Lines are synchronous. So regardless of the speed chosen, transfers will be the same in both directions.
IDSL is basically ISDN. IDSL is ideal for those customers who are too far from the central office to obtain either ADSL or SDSL services. The speed on this service is symmetrical, but it is fixed at 144 Kbps.
How do T1 and DSL Internet Access Compare?
| FeaturE | T1 | DSL |
| Main Advantage | Quality | Cost |
| Target | Organization with mission-critical need for high-speed connectivity, including web hosting and company-wide access. | Small businesses and residential users requiring cost-effective alternative for high-speed access. |
| Speed | Speed 384k - 1.5mb (at all times) | 128k - 2.0mb (speeds and synchronous transmission is not guaranteed) |
| Government Regulation | Regulated -- State and FCC regulations mandate minimum cost escalation, defined quality levels, and customer service responsiveness. | Unregulated -- There are no State and FCC regulations in place. Circuit
cost escalations, defined quality levels, and customer service responsiveness
are at the discretion of Verizon or other local Bell and the third party
DSL provider. |
| Speed vs. Distance | Guaranteed fixed speeds, independent of distance. | Speed is dependent on distance from telco central office - the farther away, the slower the speed. Synchronous transmission cannot be guaranteed. |
| Distance Limit | No limitations on distance from CO. | Limited to 3.5 miles from CO. |
| Circuit Availability | T1 circuits are widely available. | Limited availability -not all towns served. |
| Physical Circuit | T1 circuits are engineered for digital data transmission and may be delivered via fiber optic | DSL connections are made from voice-grade copper telephone circuits. Fiber, bridges or taps on circuit will prohibit DSL. |
| Connection | T1 service offers private point-to-point dedicated connection between the customer and Tier 1 backbone network -- there is no middleman. | DSL is provided through a third-party vendor and is connected via
a shared, switched ATM network. A number of customers are aggregated
at multiple single connection points (DSLAM in each DSL Central office).
Each aggregation point is a potential point of failure. |
| Installation | T1 circuit installation process is predictable averaging 40 business days. | DSL installation is uncertain and can be problematic, ranging from
40 days to 90 days plus. At least 10 percent of orders will never be
installed due to telco issues. |
| Circuit Repairs | FCC mandates a one-hour repair response from telco providers, once a trouble ticket on T1 circuits is opened. | DSL connections are treated as voice-grade circuits. This means the telco will not respond to trouble tickets until the next business day. |
Pricing |
Pricing Ranges from $399 to $649 PLUS local loop (direct telco connection from you to Verizon Central Office) | Ranges from $139.99 - $399.00 |